For a long time, I believed that a good decision was one I could explain.
If the numbers made sense, the timing was right, and I could lay out a reasonable argument for why something was the right choice, I felt pretty confident moving forward. and to be fair, logic has its place. It's an important part of making thoughtful decisions.
But I've come to realize that being able to explain why something makes sense doesn't necessarily mean it feels right to live with.
Sometimes we make decisions based on what looks good on paper, what other people would understand, or what we've been taught we're supposed to want. We weigh the practical considerations, consider the pros and cons, and arrive at an answer that seems perfectly reasonable.
And then something feels off.
It can be difficult to identify what that feeling is, especially when there's no obvious reason for it. Nothing is necessarily wrong. The house is nice, the relationship is good, the timing for a new job makes sense. So we question ourselves. Maybe we're overthinking it. Maybe we're being unrealistic. Maybe we should just be grateful for what we've found.
I've started to recognize this pattern in more areas of my life than I initially expected. Sometimes we can see all the reasons something should work, and hear those same reasons reflected back to us by the people around us. When nothing is obviously wrong, it can feel difficult to give much weight to the quiet sense that something isn't quite right. Especially when we can't fully explain why.
But I wonder how often that feeling is less about indecision and more about something we haven't quite taken the time to understand.
A decision can be perfectly logical and still overlook something important. It might not account for the way you want to spend your time, the things that have become priorities, the kind of environment you need, or even the person you're becoming.
Those things aren't always easy to put into a spreadsheet or explain in a conversation. But that doesn't make them any less relevant.
I'm not suggesting we abandon logic or make decisions based on feelings alone. It's more about recognizing that the two don't have to compete. Practical considerations help us understand what's possible. Our lived experience helps us understand what's meaningful.
Sometimes the most useful thing we can do when a decision doesn't feel quite right is resist the urge to explain the feeling away.
Maybe there's something worth paying attention to.
Because a good decision shouldn't just make sense when you explain it to someone else. It should make sense in the context of the life you're actually trying to live.
If this sounds like something you’re sitting with, you’re welcome to keep dwelling on it. Subscribe to the newsletter →
Or, if you’d like to talk it through, book a Clarity Session →
